1. Prepare the Peanut Butter Custard Filling
In a medium saucepan, whisk together the sugar, flour, and salt.
Gradually whisk in the milk until smooth.
Cook over medium heat, stirring constantly, until the mixture thickens and bubbles (about 8-10 minutes).
2. Temper the Egg Yolks
Slowly pour 1 cup of the hot milk mixture into the beaten egg yolks, whisking constantly to prevent scrambling.
Pour the tempered yolks back into the saucepan and cook for 2 more minutes, stirring until thickened.
3. Add Peanut Butter & Flavorings
Remove from heat and stir in the peanut butter, butter, and vanilla until completely smooth.
4. Assemble the Pie
Pour the warm filling into the pre-baked pie crust.
Smooth the top with a spatula and press plastic wrap directly onto the surface to prevent a skin from forming.
5. Chill & Serve
Refrigerate for at least 4 hours (or overnight) until fully set.
Before serving, top with whipped cream, chopped peanuts, or a chocolate drizzle if desired.
Pro Tips for the Best Pie
🔹 Use regular peanut butter – Natural peanut butter can make the filling oily.
🔹 Don’t skip tempering the eggs – This ensures a silky texture, not scrambled bits!
🔹 Prevent cracks – Pressing plastic wrap on the surface keeps it creamy.
🔹 Make ahead – This pie tastes even better the next day as flavors meld.
Serving Suggestions & Variations
Crushed Oreo crust – For a chocolate-peanut butter twist.
Mini pies – Use muffin tins for individual servings.
Sugar-free option – Swap sugar for a keto-friendly sweetener.
Fluffier texture – Fold in whipped cream before chilling.
FAQs
Q: Can I use a store-bought crust?
A: Absolutely! A pre-made graham cracker or pastry crust works perfectly.
Q: Why is my filling lumpy?
A: Likely from uneven heat—whisk constantly and temper eggs properly.
Q: How long does this pie last?
A: Up to 4 days refrigerated (if it lasts that long!).
Final Thoughts
This Amish Peanut Butter Cream Pie is the ultimate creamy, nostalgic dessert—simple enough for weeknights but special enough for celebrations. One bite will transport you to a cozy Amish bakery!
Ready to make it? Gather your ingredients and treat yourself to a slice of peanut butter heaven!